Spud Sunday: The Return Of The Spud Shake

When I saw that somebody had used the search terms “Potato Mc Shake” and ended up at The Daily Spud, I knew that it was time to revisit my potato shake, before the giants of the fast food industry stole my thunder.

So I boldly returned to where only I (to the best of my knowledge) had boldly gone before and went back to work on the spud shake formula, enlisting a few skeptical guinea pigs to sample the results.

In the end, there wasn’t that much to it. I took the basic formula of spuds, milk, honey and lecithin that had made its debut chez Aoife Mc, added a bit of salt, and topped up with mango for version one and banana for version two. The skeptics were really not quite so skeptical afterward and declared banana the winner and themselves spud shake survivors, which makes them members of a really, as yet, rather exclusive club!

And so, without further ado, I give you the spud shake formula and wonder when it will happen that future searches for “Potato Mc Shake” will bring the world, not to my door, but to the latest, em, “innovation” by a certain well-known fast food emporium…

Potato Shake, Now With Mango

Potato Shake, Now With Mango

  Print It

Spud Shake: The Potato Milkshake, Two Ways

You may (or may not) find it reassuring to note that this does not actually contain a lot of potato. For the amount specified here (which, I would say, makes 2 small, thick shakes), you’d need less than one average-sized spud, so you may as well cook up more than that and use the remaining specimens for something more conventional. You can also add more milk if you prefer it not to be quite so thick.

The Base Shake:
  • 50g cooked potato
  • 100ml milk
  • pinch of salt
  • 1 tblsp honey
  • 1 tblsp lecithin granules
The Fruity Bit:
  • 200g fresh mango chunks (flesh from 1 ripe mango)
  • or
  • 1 ripe banana
You’ll also need:
  • A blender
The Steps:
  • You need just a small amount of potato which has been boiled or steamed and then allowed to cool (so, as noted above, do cook more than one spud, you’ll always find a use for the others).
  • Add the cooled potato, milk, fruit (either the banana or mango) and a pinch of salt to the blender and (guess what) blend.
  • Now add the honey. Start with just one or two tsp, blend and taste and add more if you like.
  • Add the lecithin granules and blend. You can leave the lecithin out if you like, but it really does improve the texture of the shake.
  • Now take a deep breath, pour and drink. It’s really not that bad!
The Variations:
  • Well, I figure if you’re game enough to get this far, you might have variations of your own that you’ll want to try.
The Results:
  • This probably amounts to spud shake for 2. It’s quite rich and thick, so you really don’t need big portions. That, coupled with the fact that (if you tell them what’s in it) people are going to think it strange enough to only want a small amount to begin with anyway!
Update: Because I think that it’s only right and proper that the spud shake should keep company with other fine potato-y creations, this goes out to the Potato Ho Down, being hosted this month by Krysta at Evil Chef Mom on June 17th.

Comments
  • Interesting recipe! Looking forward to trying it…and I got some taters in my veg box yesterday so I have all these ingredients…except the lecithin granules…any ideas for a replacement?

  • Go, DS, go! I’d bet that adding that bit of salt makes a huge difference. IMO, it’s lack of salt that makes pumpkin pie always taste so flat to me. For goodness’ sake, it’s a vegetable. Give it some salt! I can see where folks might prefer the banana shake, since the texture of blended banana is thick and creamy, but I’m going to go with the mango version, I think. Or, hey–how about a coconut version? Change the milk to coconut milk, add a bit of lime juice and Voila–the spud colada!!

  • Jenni’s on to something – a Spud Colada sounds awesome. But everything brilliant has to start at the beginning and that would be your Spud Shake 2.0! The richer and thicker, the better to spoon it. The only thing that stops me from making this immediately is that we killed our blender a while back and have yet to replace it. But this will be the recipe with which we will inaugurate our new one!

  • hmmmm, very interesting! i’m so not a fan of bananas or mangos, but potato shakes intrigue me!

  • I’d go for a spud colada. =) Well done. A new way to take in the potato. I like that you added some mango. Give it a little fruity flavor. I will have to try this one for sure as I’ve never had a spud shake.

  • i’m intrigued! and i also love that someone even came up with the search term “potato mcshake”!! hilarious! the banana sounds yummy. one of my favorite smoothie flavors!!

  • Something I never would have imagined. Creative for sure and I would be daring enough to give it a try. I have no doubt it is a pleasant surprise. I’ll have to go with the mango. :)

  • gastroanthropologist: well, if you don’t have issues with using raw eggs, an egg yolk would be one alternative source of lecithin and would probably have a similar emulsifying effect (but then you’ve got a raw egg spud shake, which is something a bit different…)

    Jenni: the spud colada? genius! (though “patata colada” might work better for the inevitable advertising campaign and subsequent hit single)

    Tangled Noodle: I’m just wondering what it was you were making that caused the death of your blender? is it a blogworthy tale?

    kickpleat: it is an intriguing concept – took me a while to get my own head around the idea!

    jenn: not many people have had one of these :)

    Heather: yep, banana in a smoothie is a favourite of mine too

    Lori: I thought you might go for the mango option alright :)

  • The tale of the blender’s demise rests on my propensity to freeze and forget: I purchased a bag of frozen mango cubes which was ultimately buried under sundry ice-encased foodstuff in the freezer. Then, like a wooly mammoth discovered in the permafrost, I found it during the spring thaw. I had visions of a mango smoothie; what I didn’t realize is that much like the aforementioned mammoth, the mangos had become petrified . . . poor, poor blender.

  • I think these are interesting recipes! I would never have thought about using potatoes in a drink! hahaha,…but it looks really appetizing!! MMMMM….

  • I love it – Potato Mc SHake! LOL. This looks like an interesting recipe – i must try. Hey if you have time could you check out a blog event I am hosting – I would love to unite the worlds of gluten-free and non-gluten-free food bloggers. I am on a mission! I would be so happy if you could participate. check it out http://simplygluten-free.blogspot.com/2009/05/go-ahead-honey-its-gluten-free-june.html

  • It’s so crazy I love it. You have, have, have to enter this in June’s Potato Ho Down because it is SO COOL!

  • I’m with Tangled Noodle–no blender here, but how creative!

  • Now this is different for sure. You’re so good at coming up with these potato recipes!

  • I love this! I guess I missed it the first time, so I stumbled it in case any other sad sacks like me missed it too. GREG

  • This is completely interesting. I’d never think to put a bit of potato in a shake before!!

  • Nom. Who’d have thought it eh? A spud smoothie! Loving the Lecithin (BTW if you’re a bit interested in the science stuff, you must bag a copy of McGee on Food & Cooking) and the Spud Colada is sounding very promising! x

  • Oh my, I really like the sound of this! I guess I missed the first one as well…

    Can you email me, do not know if you have seen I cannot make it upstairs to my desk top for your information, and need to talk with you…

  • Tangled Noodle: yikes, a cautionary tale of mammoth proportions!

    Sophie: they were surprisingly good…

    Carol: I will have to get my thinking cap on for that gluten-free event and see what I can come up with for your manly Hugh Jackman theme :)

    noble pig: I will enter, I will!

    laura: thanks, you’re too kind

    Duo Dishes: guess I have just a wee bit of a potato-fixation, which can sometimes have interesting results :)

    Greg: hey, you are anything but a sad sack my friend!

    Lori: well, I guess not many people would have thought if it, lol

    English Mum: who would have thought it indeed – I think it’s a case of “the little potato who could” :) And will check out that book – the science stuff is definitely up my alley.

    Chef E: will do…

  • I could totally see those purple potatoes in this frothy concoction, the fruit addition sounds lovely, you had me thinking along the lines of a lassie of spuds, but my rhyming ability is gone. Maybe the Purple Mammoth in honor of TN’s deceased blender.

  • How interesting! I like potatoes no matter how you make them, but this is definitely a new way that I have yet to try!

  • […] loved my mini cheese, potato and onion pies, while Saveur liked my salt-baked baby potatoes. My potato milkshake, though, was enough to strike fear into the heart of grown men. I can only assume that I must have […]

  • […] be honest, potato milkshakes aside, my culinary experiments don’t normally extend to the beverage side of the house. […]

  • […] a little wave of excitement, she reminded the reader about the potato milkshake that had caused grown men to positively quake in their boots. The Infamous Spud […]

  • Wow. Never would’ve thought you could make shake using potatoes, but I’m keen to give it a try!

  • I tell ya, Marisa, it’s a revelation!

  • […] potato doughnuts and potato milk jam – the latter a recipe that was right up there with the spud shake in the unusual (and, for some, challenging) spud recipes league. In other words, it had my name […]

  • Anything you'd like to add...?

    (required)

    (required)